Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Barbara Roberts's avatar

Has Samuel James made any acknowledgment or response to your critiques, Aaron?

Expand full comment
Barbara Roberts's avatar

In my opinion, Timothy Keller’s tweet was an example of the language of spiritual abuse. Two things he said make me come to that view.

1. Keller used absolutist language: “nothing more important...” No room for shades of grey there. No room for individuals having different priorities that the one Keller insists on.

2. “Have to” comes across like an order, a command. This is especially so when a pastor or celebrity leader says “we have to” or “you have to”. Commands are hard and insistent -- they allow for no exceptions. No discussion. No negotiation. “You should” or “we should” can come across as even harsher. (I call “should” the S word on Christianese.)

Non-abusive discourse uses invitational / exhortational language. “Let us...” is a good example.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts